set_hp(0) and fall damage runs into armor healing

[Bastrabun]

Sometimes, we want to kill people.

Then we do player:set_hp(0), but if the armor the player wears has some healing properties, we can't kill them.

Repro:

• use latest MTG, 3d_armor and 5.4.1
• wear diamond armor
• do /killme
  => In some cases, you are still alive. Other mods may also have this issue

IMO set_hp(0) should do exactly that: kill the player.

Also, fall damage seems to count against the heal property.

Could you please make it that high fall damage and set_hp(0) does not let anyone live?

Or could you make it that armors can register against what type of damage they help?

For my reference 998

[BuckarooBanzay]

Sometimes, we want to kill people.

That's a good way to start a conversation 😆

Could you please make it that high fall damage and set_hp(0) does not let anyone live?

Do you have an idea how to achieve this?

[Bastrabun]

In the register_on_player_hpchange you decide when to apply damage and when heal catches it.

1. You could make it a public function, so that we can override it.
2. You could make the globalstep function public as well, so we can add custom aoe
3. You could iterate through a table of damage sources, which bring damage functions with them

This way, a game could select to apply the heal (rather a "deflect") value to falling damage or to ignore it. Imagine falling off a cliff in full plate mail. Sure, the plate would prevent bruises, but the person would die regardless of sudden deceleration.

Also, set_hp allows to provide custom reasons. In a game where laser damage is a thing and a coat of mirrors deflects lazer pew pew, but not missiles, they could specify set_hp(1000,"pewpew") on hit. My game will introduce blunt, slash and stab damage, also magic and others, even combinations of those.

[fluxionary]

IMO, as a start, the kill command that's part of builtin should provide a reason to the player:set_hp call...